Pay My Bill

Relief for Illinois and Missouri Customers Impacted by Recent flooding

All Customers Except Flood

Four convenient ways to pay:

  1. One-time payments (installment fees apply)

    Pay My Bill

  2. Self-service payments:

    Login to Pay My Bill Create a New Account

  3. Call (800) 974-7400 for automated phone payments (have your bill account # ready)
  4. Mail payments to:
    Regular mail
    Selective
    Box 371468
    Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
    Overnight/express mail
    Selective 
    500 Ross St. Room 154-0470
    Pittsburgh, PA 15262
    Attn: Box 371468

VISA® and MasterCard® accepted for all Personal Lines accounts, and Commercial Lines accounts with a total premium of less than $25,000.

Note: If you are billed directly by your insurance agency, please contact them for information on your payment alternatives.

Flood Customers

Selective offers a variety of flood payment options to choose from 24/7:

  1. Self-service payments:

    Login to Pay My Bill Create a New Account

  2. Call (800) 747-3576 to make a payment with your credit card*
  3. Mail payments to:

Regular mail
Selective – Flood
PO Box 782747
Philadelphia, PA 19178-2747

Overnight/express mail
Selective – Lockbox # 2747
401 Market Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106

*Visa®, Mastercard®, American Express® and Discover® are accepted for new, renewal and rollover flood payments. Payments by check should be made out to Selective Insurance and include your policy number on the check.